Old Lyme Real Estate Search

Old Lyme Properties for Sale

Our website features the best Old Lyme real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Old Lyme real estate market? Sign up for a  Old Lyme Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Newest Old Lyme Properties for Sale

$565,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 24033663 MLS
Stunning Colonial home offering 3-bedrooms, 2-bathrooms and a 2 bay garage nestled on a lightly wooded .94 acre lot in a Cul-de-Sac neighborhood close to beaches and shopping. This impeccably maintained home features a front to back formal living room with hardwood floors, pocket door, woodstove fireplace and access out to the rear trex deck. The beautifully remodeled eat-in kitchen is appointed with granite counters, tiled backsplash, white cabinets, SS appliances, tiled floors, pantry and a breakfast bar. The formal dining room features cathedral wood ceilings that opens into the family room boasting a large front window letting in tons of natural light. The first-floor remodeled full bathroom offers natural stone flooring, chair rail, pedestal sink, full tub/shower combination with a tiled surround and a built-in storage cabinet. The upper level features the front to back primary bedroom with ceiling fan, chair rail and a walk-in closet. Two more generously sized bedrooms on the upper level both offer ample closet space and hardwood floors. The second full bathroom has radiant heat in the tiled floor, dual sinks and a tiled surrounded full tub/shower combination. The unfinished lower-level offers has walkout access to the 2-bay garage and potential for added space. The large rear deck overlooks the partially fenced-in rear yard with a stunning paver walkway and patio to a firepit perfect for roasting marshmallows on the summer evenings. This home is move in ready!!!

24 Champlain Drive, Old Lyme

$825,000
5 Beds 3 Baths 24030692 MLS
Step back in time and into the charm of this meticulously maintained 1820s Colonial home, ideally situated near picturesque beaches. Nestled on Neck Road, this historic gem seamlessly blends period details with modern comforts, offering a unique blend of old-world charm and contemporary convenience. As you approach, be greeted by the classic New England facade framed by mature trees and manicured landscaping. Step inside to discover a beautifully updated interior, where historic touches such as wide plank floors, and original woodwork have been lovingly preserved. The heart of the home is a chef's dream - an updated kitchen featuring stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, ample cabinet space, and an oversized pantry. Adjacent, the spacious dining area beckons for intimate dinners or festive gatherings. Modern comfort is paramount with newly updated bathrooms that marry functionality with elegance, offering spa-like retreats with tiled showers and luxurious fixtures. For practicality and peace of mind, this home boasts recent upgrades including a new septic system, boiler, and chimney liner, ensuring efficiency for years to come. Enjoy year-round relaxation in the heated sunroom, where sunlight filters through large windows, creating a serene oasis perfect for morning coffee or afternoon reading. For those seeking a blend of history, character, and modern convenience, this Colonial home offers an unparalleled opportunity to own a piece of New England's stories.

15 Neck Road, Old Lyme

$445,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 24028242 MLS
Nestled privately in Old Lyme this dream retreat is located 2 miles north of Old Lyme village. A grand front porch is the a perfect perch to enjoy the surroundings. Inside, there are light, traditional log walls and beamed ceilings. Great flow starts in the living room with fireplace and wood stove insert. A well-planned kitchen with stainless appliances and a grilling hearth opens to the dining room. There is a first-floor primary bedroom with adjacent full bath and second bedroom currently used as a large closet. Upstairs, find a large bedroom with generous closets and built ins. This is a second primary bedroom option. Next door is a den/office with built ins and partially open to the great room below. There is a large full basement and loads of storage.The home has oil heat downstairs, electric upstairs and a pellet stove. Rock solid inside, outside the grounds are charming. The rear deck is a second great nook for relaxing and birdwatching. While 2 acres, the lawn is just the right size and the woodlands provide privacy. Find a shed for projects and extra storage. Explore Rogers Lake, Old Lyme beaches, nearby 500+ acres at the Lay Allen and McCullough preserves, walkable from the house and entrance on Lord's Meadow Road. Explore the beauty of the lower CT River Valley! 20 and 40 minutes to Groton/New London and Hartford. Driveway needs regrading a covered former pool on property can be removed or improved. Great property!

215-2 Boston Post Road, Old Lyme

$465,000
5 Beds 2 Baths 24027842 MLS
Explore this exceptional investment opportunity in Old Lyme, CT, ideally positioned right off I-95 and close to the picturesque White Sand Beach Town Beach. This property features two separate units, making it a versatile choice for investors interested in both long-term rentals and short-term accommodations such as Airbnb, or for owner-occupants seeking a residence that can also generate income. The front unit offers a practical layout with three bedrooms and one bathroom, perfect for families or individuals looking for accessible, comfortable living. The second unit includes two bedrooms and one bathroom, complemented by an attached garage, adding convenience and value. This arrangement is ideal for owner-occupants looking to offset their mortgage payments and increase cash flow through rental income. Located near a popular local attraction, the property's proximity to the beach enhances its appeal for short-term vacation rentals while maintaining steady demand for long-term leases. This strategic location not only provides excellent rental income potential but also offers flexibility in rental strategy to adapt to various market needs and preferences. Whether you're looking to expand your rental portfolio, start in real estate investment, or find a home that helps pay for itself, this multi-unit property in Old Lyme represents a smart buy with significant income potential, ideal for diversifying your investment approach.

7 Griswold Avenue, Old Lyme

$695,000
24019567 MLS
This well-established restaurant offers a unique and captivating dining experience, situated amidst the picturesque beauty of expansive marsh views. Nestled in the heart of a charming shoreline town, where the Connecticut River meets Long Island Sound, the location adds a distinctive charm to the culinary venture. The surrounding area is a vibrant region with art galleries, shopping opportunities, and a lively beach community, drawing in additional patrons during the summer months. With a rich history spanning over 33 years, this restaurant has become a culinary favorite in the community. Boasting a spacious interior, it provides a variety of seating options. The large first-floor dining room immerses patrons in the natural beauty of marsh views. Ascending to the second floor, a dining loft space continues to offer breathtaking panoramic views of the marsh. Adding to its versatility, the restaurant features two private dining rooms. These private spaces offer a spacious setting for special gatherings, community events, and celebrations. The bar area is a focal point of socializing, with a full circular bar complemented by additional table seating. The business is being offered as a turn-key operation including furnishings, tables, chairs, barstools, glassware, stemware, dishes, plates, beverages and liquor. In addition, the sale includes the computer systems ensuring a seamless transition. A rare opportunity for an entrepreneur to step into an established business.

19 Halls Road, Old Lyme

$2,000,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 24015591 MLS
Salisbury Place is a stunning, pristine property in the heart of Old Lyme village. Sited on over an acre of flat, professionally manicured and mature grounds, this home is move-in ready both inside and out. Suitable for an antique lover, one who desires character and grace, or someone looking for modern amenities, Salisbury Place delivers on all fronts. Much of this property has been recently updated and reconfigured to the highest standards. The kitchen was moved to create a modern space adjoining the wood-paneled family room, the bluestone patio, the newly formed mudroom and the garage. Now with an eat-in space, there is room for a large table overlooking the private and beautifully landscaped backyard. The dining room, with built-in bar and fireplace, gleams with light, sophistication and charm. The library features gorgeous detailed woodwork, a large bow window, and a spectacular marble fireplace. The primary suite encompasses a large, vaulted ceiling bathroom with a deep soaking tub and double sinks, a study with fireplace, plus two walk-in closets. Two additional bedrooms and bath round off the second floor. The third floor contains two bedrooms, a sitting room, and a full bath. The home also boasts an expansive, wood paneled multipurpose room over the post and beam garage. A Buderus boiler, a whole house generator, and a wood shingle roof are just some of the recent structural and mechanical updates to the home. This property is truly a perfect, elegant gem!

5 Mccurdy Road, Old Lyme

$1,998,700
4 Beds 4 Baths 24013172 MLS
Imagine a time when artists lived and loved on the CT shoreline nearly a century ago... When you arrive at this 6.75-acre estate set far back on Sill Lane with water frontage south and west, you'll be immersed in privacy and quiet. The unparalleled attention to detail relaxes-with the expansive lush green lawn, boxwoods, and roses. Walk into your graciously appointed home and enter the life of the Roaring '20s. Simplicity at its best. Special touches include arched doorways, French doors, and fir hardwood floors. The patio off the dining room-combined with the butler's pantry and kitchen with high cathedral ceiling-provides excellent flow for hosting lively dinner parties. The living room, set with a warm wood-burning fireplace, offers a magical setting for sharing ideas and limitless views of the flowing Lieutenant River. Pass into the sunroom and be one with nature-3 walls of glass, cathedral ceilings, and HVAC-your new favorite room. Just a slider away, you'll step out to the piece de resistance: the patio of life! You'll be immersed in nature and transported to a whimsical time, not lost in this idyllic backdrop. Unparallel birdwatching, a pair of Bald Eagles, garden area, and soccer field complete the experience. There's much more to this charming home. The current owner has updated the cedar shingle roof, HVAC, well pump, painting, landscaping, and Level II EV charging in the 2-car garage. Long Island Sound is just a few paddles down the River from the dock

32 Sill Lane, Old Lyme

$825,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 170623921 MLS
Marvel at this exquisite waterfront sanctuary nestled in Old Lyme! A stone-paved driveway welcomes you to meticulously landscaped grounds merging seamlessly with Duck Bay. This neighborhood offers access to Watch Rock Preserve, Duck Bay canoe launch, and Katherine Road's water access. Whether indoors or out, soak in the serene vistas from every angle. Step onto the expansive deck, ideal for basking in the sun, hosting lively gatherings, or sizzling up a storm on the grill. Inside, the open-concept layout exudes charm and sophistication. Windows flood the space with endless natural light and captivating views. Retreat to the first-floor master suite or accommodate guests in the equally inviting guest bedroom. A versatile full heated loft space and finished room above the detached garage offer additional flexibility for various needs. Embrace unobstructed views year-round, thanks to underground utilities, while a separate office/studio with its own entrance provides a serene workspace. Settle onto the vast deck and drink in the panoramic sights of the Connecticut River, Fenwick, and Long Island Sound on the horizon. Conveniently located near tennis courts, golf courses, marinas, farmers' markets, art galleries, restaurants and every day presents endless opportunities for exploration and enjoyment. And with New York and Boston just a two-hour drive away, this waterfront haven offers both seclusion and accessibility in equal measure.

28 Katherine Road, Old Lyme

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the SMARTMLS Internet Data Exchange program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms, and is provided by SMARTMLS through a licensing agreement. Listing information is from various brokers who participate in the SMARTMLS IDX program and not all listings may be visible on the site. The property information being provided on or through the website is for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers and such information may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Some properties which appear for sale on the website may no longer be available because they are for instance, under contract, sold or are no longer being offered for sale. Property information displayed is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. Copyright 2024 SmartMLS, Inc.